Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutPACKET Estes Park Planning Commission 2021-11-16PLANNING COMMISSION – TOWN OF ESTES PARK TO BE HELD VIRTUALLY Tuesday, November 16, 2021 1:30 p.m. Estes Park, CO 80517 The Estes Park Board Planning Commission will participate in the meeting remotely due to the Declaration of Emergency signed by Town Administrator Machalek on March 19, 2020, related to COVID-19 and provided for with the adoption of Ordinance 04-20 on March 18, 2020. Procedures for quasi-judicial virtual public hearings are established through Emergency Rule 06-20 signed by Town Administrator Machalek on May 8, 2020, and outlined below. Please click the link below to join the webinar: https://zoom.us/j/93771272278 Or Join by Telephone: 1.Dial US: +1 833-548-0276 (toll free) 2.Enter Webinar ID: 937 7127 2278 followed by # The meeting will also be live-streamed on the Town’s Youtube Channel and recorded and posted to YouTube and www.estes.org/videos within 48 hours. Public Comment When the moderator opens up the public comment period for an agenda item, attendees wishing to speak shall: 1. Click the “Raise Hand” button, if joining online on the Zoom client, or 2. Press *9 and follow the prompts if joining by telephone. 3. If you are watching live on YouTube, please call the number listed above, and mute your computer audio for the duration of your remarks. Once you are announced, please state your name and address for the record. To participate online via Zoom, you must: •Have an internet-enabled smartphone, laptop or computer. •Using earphones with a microphone will significantly improve your audio experience. The Town of Estes Park will make reasonable accommodations for access to Town services, programs, and activities and special communication arrangements for persons with disabilities. Please call (970) 577-4777. TDD available. Prepared November 11, 2021 111 NOTE: The Planning Commission reserves the right to consider other appropriate items not available at the time the agenda was prepared. AGENDA PLANNING COMMISSION – TOWN OF ESTES PARK Tuesday, November 16, 2021 1:30 p.m. 1.AGENDA APPROVAL 2.PUBLIC COMMENT. (Please state your name and address). 3.CONSENT AGENDA: 1.Planning Commission Minutes dated October 19, 2021 4.AGENDA ITEMS 1.RE-1 Removal Code Amendment Director Garner Staff requests continuance of this item to a date uncertain 2.Minor Subdivision 325 James Street Senior Planner Woeber Staff requests continuance of this item to the December 21, 2021 meeting 3.ADU Code Amendment Planner II Bergeron 5.DISCUSSION ITEMS 1.Code Amendment RM-2 Ayres/Director Garner 2.Comprehensive Plan Director Garner 3.2022 Strategic Plan Director Garner 4.Solar Incentives update Director Garner 5.Community Planning Assistance for Wildfire update Planner II Bergeron 6.REPORTS Director Garner 7.ADJOURN Prepared 11/11/2021 222 333 Town of Estes Park, Larimer County, Colorado, October 19, 2021 Minutes of a Regular meeting of the ESTES PARK PLANNING COMMISSION of the Town of Estes Park, Larimer County, Colorado. Meeting held VIRTUALLY in said Town of Estes Park on the 19 day of October 2021. Committee: Chair Matt Comstock, Vice-Chair Matthew Heiser, Commissioners Joe Elkins, Howard Hanson, Janene Centurione. Attending: Chair Comstock, Vice-Chair Heiser, Commissioner Elkins, Commissioner Hanson, Director Jessica Garner, Senior Planner Jeff Woeber, Planner II Alex Bergeron, Recording Secretary Karin Swanlund, Attorney Dan Kramer, Town Board Liaison Barbara MacAlpine Absent: Centurione Chair Comstock called the meeting to order at 1:30 p.m. Also attending were Logan Graves and Mike Scholl, Ayres Associates consultants. AGENDA APPROVAL It was moved and seconded (Heiser/Hanson) to approve the agenda. The motion passed 4-0. PUBLIC COMMENT. Due to technical issues, the public was not let into the meeting until 1:45 p.m. Attorney Kramer noted that public comment is not typically allowed on discussion items. Two members of the public were allowed to speak later in the meeting, both expressing their frustration of not being able to join at the start. CONSENT AGENDA APPROVAL It was moved and seconded (Hanson/Elkins) to approve the consent agenda. The motion passed 4-0. DISCUSSION ITEMS 1.Planner II Bergeron continued discussion on the proposed code amendment regarding Accessory Dwelling Units (ADU’S). Code language revisions since the last meeting consist of eliminating the off-street parking requirement and prohibition of home occupation provisions. Enforcement of minimum lot size for the zoning district sets clear language on what properties ADUs will be allowed. Variances for “uses” are not allowed. Bergeron reviewed questions brought up by the public, including that 30-day rentals are universally accepted as “long-term rentals” in local codes and don’t require property management; ADU’s are very different from Vacation Homes; street parking will be allowed where it is already permitted and not permitted where it currently isn’t. It was agreed to bring this Code Amendment to the November 16 Planning Commission meeting for public hearing. Public Comment: Rick Ralph, 395 Park View Lane, commented on the lack of restrictions. Note: most comments were inaudible. It was requested Mr. Ralph submit an email outlining his concerns. 2.Mike Scholl, Ayres Associates, spoke on strategies to increase attainable housing supply. Staff identified a new density bonus zone district as one viable solution, RM-2. This zone district would increase general housing production and incentivize attainable housing development. Two tiers of bonuses would be enabled: Tier 1 (base entitlement) would allow up to 16 units per acre; Tier 2 would allow up to 32 units per acre (4x the current RM/Residential-multifamily zone). Questions for discussion were proposed, including where would RM-2draft444 Planning Commission – October 19, 2021 – Page 2 apply, what standards would apply and the targeted population. Considerable debate on these questions was had. Director Garner stated that proposals would be thoroughly researched and evaluated using existing criteria. Attorney Kramer pointed out that rezoning standards are in the Development Code, and it is the job of the Planning Commission to determine if the plan is in line with the Comprehensive Plan. A video presentation created by Ayres of 32 units/acre developments will be shared with the Commission. This amendment will be revisited at the December 21 Planning Commission Meeting, and an online public forum will be scheduled before that time. 3. Director Garner reviewed the RE-1 Zoning District, explaining that it is a residential zoning district that requires a 10-acre minimum lot size. There are only three parcels zoned RE-1, one owned by the Town of Estes Park, the other two owned by Rocky Mountain National Park. Rezoning these parcels to RE would be the first step, followed by eliminating the RE-1 zone district from the Estes Park Development Code and the Estes Park Municipal Code. There will be a virtual community/neighborhood meeting on November 1 to discuss this. The public hearing is scheduled to take place at the November 16 Planning Commission meeting. REPORTS: Director Garner reviewed the progress of the Comprehensive Plan. Virtual visioning workshops will be held on November 3 and November 17. Public Comment: Rex Poggehpohl, town citizen, suggested the following: RM-2 zoning should be aligned along the traffic corridors, not in other residential areas; 24 units/acre instead of 32; all RM districts should have heavy buffers between zoning districts; minimum lot size should be used as well as minimum and maximum parking requirements. There being no further business, Chair Comstock adjourned the meeting at 3:25 p.m. Matt Comstock, Chair Karin Swanlund, Recording Secretary draft555 666 Memo COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT To: Estes Park Planning Commission From: Jessica Garner, AICP, Community Development Director Date: November 16, 2021 RE: Request for Continuance: RE-1 Code Amendment Staff Request: The RE-1 code amendment impacts three parcels in Estes Park; two of which are owned by Rocky Mountain National Park, and the other parcel containing a water tower is owned by the Town. RMNP indicated they would like to disconnect from the Town, and staff is reviewing their request. Staff is requesting to continue the code amendment to address the timing of both applications and the process to bring the disconnection request to the Town Board after the Planning Commission’s review and recommendation for the code amendment. Staff recommends the Planning Commission continue the RE-1 code amendment to a date uncertain, and the project will be re-noticed when a hearing date is identified. 977 888 Memo COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT To: Estes Park Planning Commission From: Jeffrey Woeber, Senior Planner Date: November 16, 2021 RE: Request for Continuance: Golden Leaf Minor Subdivision Staff Request: After recent discussion with the Town Utilities Department and the Estes Park Sanitation District, staff has determined that prior to the subdivision being ready for Planning Commission review there are water and sewer related matters to resolve. Staff recommends the Planning Commission continue the Golden Leaf Minor Subdivision to the December 21, 2021 Planning Commission meeting. 799 101010 Community Development Memo To: Chair Matt Comstock Estes Park Planning Commission Through: Jessica Garner, AICP, Community Development Director From: Alex Bergeron, Planner II Date: November 16, 2021 RE: Proposed Text Amendment to Estes Park Development Code §5.2 & §13.3 - Accessory Dwelling Units (Mark all that apply for later Town Board handling) PUBLIC HEARING ORDINANCE LAND USE CONTRACT/AGREEMENT RESOLUTION OTHER______________ QUASI-JUDICIAL YES NO Planning Commission Objective: Conduct a public hearing to consider and make a recommendation on a proposed text amendment to the Estes Park Development Code (EPDC) regarding Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs). Code Amendment Objective: The objective of this proposed code amendment is to expand access to ADU development in residential zone districts to bolster free-market solutions to the ongoing and critical housing shortage in Estes Park. Proposal: The proposed text amendments to §5.2 of the EPDC (Accessory Uses and Accessory Structures) are related to ADUs and include the following changes: • Permit ADUs in the R-1 zone district • Clarify additional requirements for ADUs • Adjust ADU size limits • Modify rental regulations • Clarify home occupation standards • Strike certain provisions • Clarify lot size changes identified in a modified Table 5-1 111111 • Add new requirements for ADUs The proposed text amendments also modify the definition of “Accessory Dwelling Unit” in EPDC §13.3 to accommodate the above changes. Staff Findings: The text amendments comply with EPDC §3.3.D (Code Amendments – Standards for Review), as outlined below: §3.3.D.1. The amendment is necessary to address changes in conditions in the areas affected. Affirmative. According to Realtor.com,1 the median sale price for a home in Estes Park was $815,445 in September 2021, up from $479,900 in September 2019 (a 70% increase in just two years). The increase in home prices is occurring at a time of rapid population growth in Colorado. This includes the population of Larimer County, which grew by 20% between 2010-2020 according to US Census data.2 Estes Park itself grew by at least 8% over the past 10 years,3 with much of the Estes Park workforce residing far outside of the Estes Valley due to a lack of housing availability and affordability. While efforts are being made to increase workforce housing in Estes Park, new development has not kept pace with demand for well over a decade. During the Planning Division’s October 6, 2021 community engagement session on ADUs, Estes Park Housing Authority Director Naomi Hawf stated that there were 778 households in search of housing and on the Au thority’s waitlist (see “Attachment 2: Community Engagement Presentation”). This doesn’t represent people who have elected not to wait for years for housing and aren’t included on the waitlist. In an effort to respond to increasing housing needs, the proposed code amendment enables the development of new residential units through a free-market approach in which property owners seeking to build an ADU on their property would more likely be able to. This change is part of a greater range of housing solutions being proposed to address the local housing shortage. ADU construction is already allowed in single-family zone districts, but is limited – including a prohibition of long-term rental of ADUs. Town leadership identified the local housing shortage as a “crisis” in 2021, and this code amendment seeks to reduce barriers to housing. Other benefits to homeowners may include the following: • Provide housing for a loved one or one in need of care • Housing for relatives or friends, or space for guests or caregivers • Additional income from rent, and options for homeowners to downsize and age in place The proposed code amendment also responds to changing demographics and household composition in the US generally and especially in communities popular with young people, in acknowledgement that married couples with children represented only 20% of all US households in 2010, down from 43% in 1940.4 §3.3.D.2. The development plan, which the proposed amendment to this Code would allow, is compatible and consistent with the policies and intent of the 121212 Comprehensive Plan and with existing growth and development patterns in the Estes Valley. Not applicable to this code amendment itself, though plans for ADU development would be reviewed for compliance with adopted codes through the building permit process; including building codes, fire codes, and the EPDC. Standard permitting practice is additionally staff’s preferred method of tracking ADU development as the process currently tracks other types of residential development, from additions and remodels to construction of single-family homes and multi-family development. §3.3.D.3. The Town, County or other relevant service providers shall have the ability to provide adequate services and facilities that might be required if the application were approved. Affirmative. Town, County or other relevant service providers would not be significantly impacted regarding their respective services and facilities if this code amendment is approved, based on the understanding that future ADU development would occur on lots already developed for residential use and with adequate service. The code amendment was presented to affected agencies (including Public Works, the Building Division, and local utilities) and no opposition was detected in the feedback received – only support for this code amendment was offered. Advantages: • The proposal is consistent with Community Wide Policy 5.2 of the Estes Park Comprehensive Plan: “Encourage housing for permanent residents of all sectors of the community that is integrated into and dispersed throughout existing neighborhoods.” Expansion of ADU development would provide for additional, more affordable housing options in Estes Park, which currently has a pronounced shortage of housing stock relative to demand, especially for households at the middle and lower end of the economic spectrum. o Specifically, the proposed code amendment expands ADU access to 702 lots, up from 600 where ADU development is currently permitted, for a total of 1302 lots eligible, or 59% of all single-family lots in Estes Park (up from 27%) (see “Attachment 3: Extension Quantification) (note: this data does not reflect potential HOA restrictions, which could cause some numbers to be effectively lower). • The proposal is consistent with Community Wide Policy 5.6: “Encourage housing infill within the existing urban area.” The proposed code amendment would expand residential development in existing neighborhoods without creating additional lots, which provides another option for homeowners and may expedite development of additional dwellings without creating additional sprawl (consider subdivision process timeline). Additionally, fewer resources are required to build ADUs, and less energy is needed to heat and cool smaller spaces, which helps to reduce greenhouse gases and our carbon footprint. • ADU development, which had a significant history in the US before the suburban patterns of housing proliferated the landscape, may strengthen the social fabric of the community as more people may be able to live, work, and play in Estes 131313 Park when they would otherwise have to commute, easing employee shortage and staff turnover for local businesses and entities, which advances Community Wide Policy 7.7: “Establish the basis for a sound tourism market and sustainable economic climate.” • ADU development may allow older community members to age in place rather than having to move out of the community for care (consider the “mother-in-law suite” or “granny flat” basis for ADU development). Older adults could also elect to live in an ADU while renting out their primary residence to augment their income. This advances Community Wide Policy 7.9: “Build on the strength of the retirement community.” Disadvantages: • Additional dwelling units in existing residential neighborhoods may , depending on the volume of development ultimately realized, cause a perception of increased in traffic and activity typical of such neighborhoods, resulting in a minimally more urban feel than longtime residents are used to and in turn leading to temporary local discontent. Action Recommended: Staff recommends Approval of the Code Amendment. Finance/Resource Impact: None identified. Level of Public Interest High. Multiple written public comments have been received regarding the proposed code amendment. Additional support has been offered through editorials written in the Estes Park Trail-Gazette by a local professional architect (July 3, 20205; October 8, 20216) and evidenced by ADU development inquiries received by the Planning Division. Despite this local support, the majority of comments received are in opposition – often citing views which contrast with the information offered during public engagement activities. Written comments received to date are available via this link: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1uOQYIf6yV1k7YmCoRuC1zJ4W7M2ytMAG/view Sample Motion: I move to recommend that the Town Board APPROVE the code amendment, in accordance with the findings as presented. I move to recommend denial of the code amendment, finding that [state findings for denial]. I move to continue the code amendment to the next regularly scheduled meeting [state reasons for continuing]. Attachments: 1. Exhibit A: Proposed Amendment to Code Text 141414 2. Community Engagement Presentation 3. Extension Quantification 1 https://www.realtor.com/realestateandhomes-search/Estes-Park_CO/overview 2 https://www.census.gov/library/stories/state-by-state/colorado-population-change-between-census-decade.html 3 https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/estesparktowncolorado 4 https://www.rstreet.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/03/89.pdf 5 https://www.eptrail.com/2020/07/05/guest-column-why-are-accessory-dwellings-not-allowed-in-estes-park/ 6 https://www.eptrail.com/2021/10/08/adus-will-help-house-essential-workers/ 151515 § 5.2 - ACCESSORY USES (INCLUDING HOME OCCUPATIONS) AND ACCESSORY STRUCTURES A. General Standards. 1. Permitted principal uses and approved special review principal uses shall be deemed to include the accessory uses, structures and activities as set forth in this Section, unless specifically prohibited. 2. See also §13.2, "Use Classifications," wherein incidental or accessory uses are sometimes included in the description of a specific principal use. When a use classification or specific use type definition in §13.2 does include permitted accessory or incidental uses, such accessory or incidental uses shall be subject to the general standards set forth in this Section, as well as any use-specific standards set forth in §5.1 or this Section. 3. All accessory uses, structures and activities shall be subject to the general, dimensional, operational and use-specific regulations set forth in this Section, in addition to the same regulations that apply to principal uses in each district. In the case of any conflict between the accessory use/structure standards of this Section and any other requirement of this Code, the standards of this Section shall control. 4. All accessory uses and structures shall comply with the following conditions: a. The accessory use or structure shall be clearly incidental and customarily found in connection with the principal use; and b. The accessory use or structure shall be conducted and/or located on the same zoning lot as the principal use; and c. There shall be unity of ownership between the principal use and the accessory use. (Ord. 15-03 #1; Ord. 08-16 § 1, Exh. A) B. Accessory Uses/Structures Permitted in the Residential Zoning Districts. 1. Table of Permitted Accessory Uses and Structures. a. Listed Accessory Uses/Structures. Table 5-1 below sets forth what types of accessory uses and structures are permitted in which residential zones. If a specific accessory use or structure is permitted in a residential zoning district, the column underneath the zoning district will be marked with a "Yes." If the accessory use or structure is not permitted in a particular zoning district, the column will be marked with a "No." If there is a reference contained in the column entitled "additional requirements," please refer to the cited section(s) for additional standards that shall apply to the specific accessory use. b. Unlisted Accessory Uses or Structures. If an accessory use or structure is not listed in Table 5-1 but satisfies all the conditions set forth in §5.2.A.4 above, it may be permitted subject to compliance with the general, dimensional and operational standards set forth in this Section. Table 5-1 Accessory Uses and Structures Permitted in the Residential Zoning Districts 161616 (Ord. 18-01 §18; Ord. 15-03 §1; Ord 6-06 §1; Ord. 03-10 §1; Ord. 05-10 §1; Ord. 21-10 §1; Ord. 19-11 §1; Ord. 08-17 §1; Ord. 20-18 §1(Exh. A)) 2. Additional Requirements for Specific Accessory Uses/Structures Permitted in the Residential Zoning Districts. a. Accessory Dwelling Units. (1) Where Permitted. Accessory dwellings shall consist of living quarters integrated either within the principal single-family detached dwelling structure on the lot or with a detached accessory structure on the same lot as the principal dwelling. Mobile homes, recreational vehicles and travel trailers shall not be used as accessory dwelling units. (2) Size of Accessory Unit. No accessory dwellings shall exceed forty-ninethirty- three percent (4933%) of the size of the habitable floor area of the principal dwelling unit or eight hundred (800) square feet, whichever is less. An accessory dwelling unit shallmay contain private sanitary facilities with hot and cold running water, and cooking and food storage facilities, and a sleeping area. (3) Limit on Tenancy. Accessory dwelling units shall not be used as short-term rental units or vacation homes. Rentals of accessory dwelling units must be for terms of 30 days or longer. (4) Density Calculations. Accessory dwelling units shall not count toward any applicable maximum residential density requirement. Accessory Use Residential Zoning District Additional Requirements "Yes" = Permitted "No" = Not Permitted "CUP" = Conditional Use Permit RE-1 RE E-1 E R R-1 R-2 RM Accessory dwelling unit Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes YesNo No No §5.2.B.2.a 1.33 times minimum lot area required Lot shall meet minimum lot area standard of the zone district as set forth in Table 4-2 Barns and stables Yes Yes Yes No No No No No None (Ord. 15-03 §1) --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- 171717 (5) Limit on Number. There shall not be more than one (1) accessory dwelling unit on a lot in addition to the principal single-family dwelling. (6) Maximum Occupancy. The combined total number of individuals that reside in the principal and accessory dwelling units shall not exceed the number that is allowed for a single household. See definition of "Household Living" in §13.2.C.28 below. (7) Off-Street Parking. At least one (1) off-street parking space shall be provided for each bedroom located in an accessory dwelling unit. (8) Home Occupations. Home occupations shall be prohibited on the site of an accessory dwelling unit. (69) Lot Area. A Llot which is the site of an accessory dwelling unit must meet or exceed area must be one and thirty-three one-hundredths (1.33) times the minimum lot size for area of the zone district in which the lot is located, as set forth in Table 4-2. (710) Other Regulations. (a) A permitted accessory dwelling unit shall comply with all other applicable site and building design, height, access and other standards for principal dwelling units in the zoning district in which the accessory dwelling will be located. (b) All accessory dwelling units shall comply with local building code requirements. (c) Accessory dwelling units, being ancillary to and under the same ownership as the principal dwelling unit on a lot, shall not be sold or conveyed separately from the principal dwelling unit. (db) In the case of any conflict between the accessory dwelling unit standards of this Section and any other requirement of this Code, the standards of this Section shall control. --- d. Home Occupations. (1) Size/Area: A home occupation shall not exceed twenty percent (20%) of the principal building floor area of the building in which the home occupation is located, excluding garage space. This size/area requirement does not apply to family home day care. (Ord. 15-03 #1; Ord. 6-06 §1) (2) Location: Home occupations are permitted in both principal dwelling units and accessory dwelling units shall be integrated within the principal building in all zoning districts that allow home occupations, though the home occupation must be integrated within the building of the related dwelling unit(s); e. Except that on lots equal to or greater than one-and-one-half (1.5) acres in size, home occupations may be located in uninhabited accessory structures. detached from the principal building. (Ord. 15-03 #1) (3) Employees: No one other than a resident of the dwelling shall be employed on site, report to work at the site or pick up supplies or products on site in the 181818 conduct of a home occupation. This prohibition also applies to independent contractors. Family home day care home occupations are exempt from this requirement. (Ord. 15-03 #1; Ord. 6-06 §1) (4) Operational: (a) There shall be no stock-in-trade other than products fabricated by artists and artisans. (b) A home occupation shall be conducted entirely within a portion of a building not within a required parking area. Outdoor play areas are permitted in conjunction with family home day care. All loose play items, such as toys and games, shall be stored inside at the close of business each day. (Ord. 6-06 §1) (c) Vehicle or equipment sales, rentals or repairs shall not be conducted as a home occupation. (d) Personal and professional services shall be provided on an appointment-only basis. (e) No home occupation shall include a sales room open to the general public, and no articles shall be exhibited, offered for sale or sold on the premises except by prior appointment. (f) There shall be no advertising of the address of the home occupation that results in attracting persons to the premises. (g) No kilns exceeding ten (10) cubic feet in size shall be permitted. (h) All home occupations shall comply with the performance standards prescribed by §7.10 of this Code. There shall be no electrical or mechanical equipment not normally found in a residential structure. (i) No home occupation shall be allowed that will create noise, dust, fumes, odors, smoke, glare, vibration, electrical hazards, fire hazards or the storage of hazardous materials or any other nuisance to a greater degree than normally experienced in the residential district in which the permit is granted. (j) For home occupations on lots with shared private water systems, written approval of the water association shall be required for home occupations that will increase the demand on the water system. (Ord. 6-6 §1) (k) Home occupations shall be prohibited on the site of a vacation home and/or accessory dwelling unit. (See §5.1.B and §5.2.B.2.a). (Ord. 02-10 §1) --- 191919 § 13.3 - Definitions of Words, Terms and Phrases --- 3. Accessory Dwelling Unit shall mean a second dwelling unit which is integrated either with a single- family detached dwelling structure or with a detached accessory structure on the same lot as the principal dwellingthat is located on the same lot as the single-family detached dwelling. "Accessory Dwelling Unit" does not include mobile homes, recreational vehicles or travel trailers. --- 202020 ACCESSORY DWELLING UNIT (ADU) Overview Informational Webinar October 6, 2021 Hosted by: Planner II Alex Bergeron abergeron@estes.org 970.577.3729 Link to video of recorded session: zoom_0.mp4 -Google Drive 212121 WHAT IS AN ADU? •An Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU)is a second dwelling unit integrated with a single-family detached dwelling that is located on the same lot."Accessory Dwelling Unit"does not include mobile homes, recreational vehicles or travel trailers and do not include “tiny homes,” which are a specific type of primary dwelling. •ADUs can take different forms •Creative, flexible and affordable option for homeowners & renters (Median home price is $659,000, Median family income is $84,400) 222222 ADUs come in various shapes and sizes 232323 WHY AMEND THE CODE? There is a pronounced housing shortage and a gap between jobs and housing which often causes people to have to commute long distances or compete for a limited supply of suitable housing or feasible lots to develop a home, which impacts the local workforce and the economy. •Seasonal hiring needs require creative housing options. For example, consider the dining experience at a short-staffed restaurant. (3,000 seasonal jobs/yr.) •The scarcity of housing available for year round or seasonal workforce in the area is reported to negatively affect at least 85% of all employers. •Challenges with staff turnover; loss of institutional knowledge, relationships with the community, and experience with local regulations. •Enhanced sense of community when folks can live where they work. Not just a place –but a community of people with pride in where they live. •Housing and development trends are changing. 242424 ADUs are known by different terms Some other common names include, but are not limited to: •“Mother in-law suite” •“Guest house” •“Granny flat” •“Carriage house” •“Basement apartment” 252525 AREN’T ADUS ALREADY ALLOWED? •Yes. ADUs are currently permitted as accessory uses in most single- family residential uses. There are currently some restrictions on which lots may have them; e.g. a lot must be 1.33x the minimum lot size in order to have an ADU. 262626 WILL THE AMENDMENT EFFECTIVELY REZONE NEIGHBORHOODS? •No. ADUs are already an allowed use for 600 single-family residential lots in Estes Park (or 27% of all such lots). These are all at least 33% larger than the minimum lot size for their respective zone districts. •The proposed code amendment seeks to expand use to any single- family residential lot which simply meets the minimum lot size for its zone district. •The amendment proposes to include the R-1 (Residential-5,000 sq. ft. minimum lot size) where ADUs are currently not permitted. 272727 WILL THE AMENDMENT DOUBLE DENSITY IN NEIGHBORHOODS? •No. If passed, the code amendment would expand ADU eligibility to an additional 702 lots, for a total 1302 single-family residential lots in town. The proposed code amendment seeks to expand use to any single-family residential lot which simply meets the minimum lot size for its zone district. •This would amount to only 59% of single-family residential lots being eligible for ADU development based on proposed minimum lot size rules. This is because 41% of subject lots are currently legally non- conforming in lot size. 282828 WILL THE AMENDMENT DOUBLE DENSITY IN NEIGHBORHOODS? (CONT.) •ADU development is also quite costly to private property owners, in terms of time and financial expense, which is why ADU development currently is not very common. You’ve really got to want it. •Parking isn’t intended to dramatically worsen, either (existing occupancy regulations allow up to eight unrelated people in a home) 292929 WILL THERE BE MORE SHORT TERM RENTALS? •No. Short term rentals are currently not allowed in ADUs and we are not proposing to allow them. •Long term rentals (30 days or longer) would be allowed. That gets at the heart of the purpose of the amendment. •The Town currently monitors for STR compliance. 303030 Thank you! Planner II Alex Bergeron abergeron@estes.org 970.577.3729 313131 323232 333333 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT To: Estes Park Planning Commission From: Mike Scholl, Planning Professional, Ayres Associates Through: Jessica Garner, AICP, Community Development Director Date: November 16, 2021 RE: Briefing Memorandum/Missing Middle – Housing Discussion Planning Commission Objective: To engage in a discussion regarding the concept of the “missing middle” housing type. Generally, the missing middle refers to housing typologies that provide higher density and blend seamlessly with existing single family and lower density development patterns. The briefing memorandum is intended to inform ongoing discussions by the Planning Commission to address critical housing needs in Estes Park and to seek solutions that take residents’ concerns into account. Background: Following the discussion at the October 19, 2021, Planning Commission meeting regarding the proposed RM-2 zoning designation, staff determined that a more nuanced approach may be required. The RM-2 zoning district idea, to create a floating zoning district to allow for denser housing developments, may be challenging to manage and administer and would not necessarily have broad community support. There was also discussion that the complexity may dampen widespread use and thus limit the impact of the district on the housing issue. The Community Development Department anticipates engaging in a more thorough code review process as part of the Comprehensive Plan update. Additionally, the Department of Local Affairs (“DOLA”) has made grant funding available to communities to address critical housing needs. There are two levels, (1) planning grants to allow communities to adopt strategies to address housing and (2) capital funding for housing projects. The capital funding is dependent on having adopted at least three strategies identified in the legislation. What is the missing middle? The missing middle refers to a planning concept that promotes new housing opportunities, through efficient use of land and resources. The housing types are intended to increase density in a manner that both blends with lower density development patterns and are more affordable. The housing types vary from duplexes to stacked triplexes as well as cottage style housing. Specifically, the types include: • Duplexes o Side by Side o Stacked 343434 • Fourplex • Courtyard building • Cottage Court • Townhome/Townhouse style • Multiplex • Triplex As a comparison, the chart below looks at the maximum density per acre for each housing type as it compares to the maximum allowable density by zoning district. For this type of housing, it is only likely to occur in the current RM zoning district. Under most zoning codes, the missing middle housing units can be artificially limited either through density restrictions or design restrictions. As an example, under the Estes Code (§4.3 - A.7.) duplexes are only allowed only in the R-2 district with a minimum lot area that is greater than single family by 9,000 square feet, see below: “7. R-2 Two-Family Residential. This district is established to encourage development of relatively denser residential housing, including two-family dwellings (duplexes) as well as single-family detached housing, primarily within the town limits of Estes Park. This zone implements the "Two-Family (R-2)" future land use designation contained in the Comprehensive Plan. District regulations will allow a minimum lot area of eighteen thousand (18,000) square feet for single-family uses and twenty-seven thousand (27,000) square feet for two-family dwellings (duplexes).” Depending on the size of the unit, a duplex can be built on a lot as small as 5,000 square feet. For further perspective, under the existing code, with a hypothetical two-acre site, a developer could build no more than three duplexes, or six housing units as compared four single family housing units in the same area for a net gain of only two housing units. 353535 Even with density and design limitations, there are some examples of the missing middle building types in Estes Park including: • 505 Fall River Lane (Figure 1) is an example of a fourplex. A two-bedroom, one bath, 724 - square foot condo within the block is on the market with a list price of $335,000. The project is with an RM zoning district and allows for long-term rentals only. The unit is part of a larger development with four total buildings and 16 units. • 516 St. Vrain Lane (Figure 2) is another example of a townhome/duplex development. The unit is within the RM zone and part of a larger development adjacent to single family residential. The listing indicates that short term rentals are allowed with a permit. It is listed as a 2 bedroom, 1 bath, 686-square foot condo with a listed asking price of $385,000. • 603 Aspen Avenue, built in 1972 is a 16-unit project spread out over three buildings, and an example of a fourplex. The units are generally two-bedroom, one bath units, under 1,000 square feet. The units can be rented long-term. Built in 1972, the units were likely spot zoned into the RM Zoning district even though the neighborhood is predominantly single family. Form-Based Code: One method to encourage more diverse housing typologies is the use of form-based codes. Form based codes diverge from traditional Euclidian land use by emphasizing the form over use and seeks to promote standards and scale. The use of form-based codes is becoming more prevalent in the land use world. Proponents of form-based code argue that the Euclidean zoning framework over-regulates parcels and limits flexibility and versatility. Under a form-based code scheme, regulations define outcomes and relationships with adjacent public spaces instead of strict adherence to formulas. The goal of form-based codes is to allow for greater diversity of development types and allow streamlined approval processes, though it does require some community education. Figure 1- 505 Fall River Figure 2 – 516 St. Vrain Lane Figure 3 - 603 Aspen Ave 363636 Conclusion/Questions: As Estes Park continues to grapple with the housing availability and affordability, the opportunity to allow for denser housing that can be built easily and consistent with existing building fabric will be essential. The following are some discussion questions for the Commission related to this topic: 1. In seeking to address the housing issue in Estes Park, how can the zoning code be used to promote the development of missing middle housing typologies? 2. What is the Commissions’ thoughts on these typologies as it relates to development patterns is Estes? Would missing middle housing typologies be embraced by the community? 3. What are the Commissions’ thoughts on the use of form-based codes and how they might be applied? 373737 Town of Estes Park Planning Commission Housing Discussion/Missing Middle 38 “Colorado’s housing affordability challenge is first and foremost one of supply.” -Shift Research Lab 39 Background •Follow up discussion to the October 19, 2021, Planning Commission meeting regarding the proposed RM-2 Zoning Designation •RM-2 •Challenging to manage district as proposed •Unclear if the market would respond •Not sure if it would achieve broader public support •Need a more nuanced approach - “Missing Middle” 40 Missing Middle –What is it? •Generally, planning concept to promote more medium density housing types. •Blend more seamlessly with single family housing types. •Duplexes •Side by Side •Stacked •Fourplex •Courtyard building •Cottage Court •Townhome/Townhouse style •Multiplex •Triplex 41 42 Duplex 2 units 43 Stacked Duplex 2-4 units 44 Fourplex 4 units (Fall River Drive) Built in 1993 45 Cottage Court 5 to 10 units 46 Townhouse 10 units (varies) •Similar development type Existing in Estes park (2003) 47 Comparison 48 Code limitation - Example “7. R-2 Two -Family Residential.This district is established to encourage development of relatively denser residential housing, including two-family dwellings (duplexes) as well as single-family detached housing, primarily within the town limits of Estes Park. This zone implements the "Two-Family (R-2)" future land use designation contained in the Comprehensive Plan. District regulations will allow a minimum lot area of eighteen thousand (18,000) square feet for single-family uses and twenty-seven thousand (27,000) square feet for two-family dwellings (duplexes).” 49 Next Steps Considerations for Added Density 50 Form Based Code “A form -based code is a land development regulation that fosters predictable built results and a high-quality public realm by using physical form (rather than separation of uses) as the organizing principle for the code. A form-based code is a regulation, not a mere guideline, adopted into city, town, or county law. A form-based code offers a powerful alternative to conventional zoning regulation.” -Form Based Codes Institute 51 Form Based Code •Allow a greater range of building types that would be compatible based on: •building scale •frontage design •intent of the specific zoning district •Reduced focus on use, and greater focus on configuration, features and functions. 52 Form Based Code -Example •Neighborhood district •Allows for a variety of building types •Focus on relationship to the public realm •Creates an economy of scale for smaller housing units 53 Conclusion/Questions 1.In seeking to address the housing issue in Estes Park, how can the zoning code be used to promote the development of missing middle housing typologies? 2.What is the Commissions’ thoughts on these typologies as it relates to development patterns is Estes? Would missing middle housing typologies be embraced by the community? 3.What are the Commissions’ thoughts on the use of form-based codes and how they might be applied? 54 3855 KEY OUTCOME AREA STRATEGIC POLICY STATEMENTS GOALS (MULTI-YEAR)OBJECTIVES (ONE-YEAR) 1. We value broad collaboration in providing exceptional guest services, including, but not limited to working with organizations such as Visit Estes Park, the Economic Development Corporation, the Chamber of Commerce, the National Park Service, and other organizations representing business and commerce. 2.A. Develop events that attract guests to Town in the winter and shoulder seasons as well as mid-week events. 2.B.1. Develop a new Town event to attract a new audience. 2.B. Continue to develop and attract diverse events and audiences. 4.A.1. Explore ways to use the Visitor Center to help promote current events in Estes Park. 2. We provide high-quality events that attract guests to the Town. 3.A. Work with public- and private-sector entities to encourage additional town destination opportunities for guests, particularly in case visitation limits in the National Park or elsewhere remain a factor. 5.A.1. Develop an arena maintenance plan/fund for the Events Complex. 4.A. Continue to monitor and adjust marketing focus to events that are branded to and successful in Estes Park.5.A.2. Shore up Museum Annex Foundation. 3. We strive to balance the impacts of visitation with the needs and quality of life of our residents. 5.A. Implement the 2019 Stanley Park Complex Master Plan projects at the Events Complex. 5.A.3. Update the conceptual design and cost estimates for the Stall Barns and develop a plan to fund the improvement. 5.B. Maintain a high level of arena footing for horse shows and rodeos at the Events Complex. 6.A.1. Work with Visit Estes Park to develop a website page specific to Visitor Services for easy access to Visitor Services Guest Information Guides and other information useful to guests. 4. We make data-driven decisions in serving our guests and residents.6.A. Implement the Visitor Services Strategic Plan. 6.B. Visitor Services will work with Visit Estes Park on developing and implementing ways to introduce new technology to help educate and entertain guests at the Visitor Center. 5. We value a well-maintained Stanley Park Complex. 6. The Town provides and encourages a high level of customer service to our guests. 7. We should balance the events we have in Town to be compatible with the character of Estes Park. Exceptional Guest Services - We are a preferred Colorado mountain destination providing an exceptional guest experience. Governmental Services and Internal Support - We provide high-quality support for all municipal services. Town of Estes Park 2022 Strategic Plan Vision: The Town of Estes Park will be an ever more vibrant and welcoming mountain community. Mission: The Mission of the Town of Estes Park is to provide high-quality, reliable services for the benefit of our residents, guests, and employees, while being good stewards of public resources and our natural setting. THERE IS NO RANK-ORDERING OR PRIORITIZATION IN THIS PLAN. ALL NUMERICAL DESIGNATIONS ARE FOR REFERENCE PURPOSES ONLY. 3956 1. We will maintain a well-trained and educated Town Staff.1.A. Implement Human Resources Strategic Plan. 2.1. Evaluate the structure of Public Art for the Town of Estes Park and make recommendations. 3.A. Explore options to improve the Town's ability to ensure diverse membership representation on Boards and Commissions. 4.B.1. Implement top priority language translation tasks for public outreach materials and/or services based on the internal evaluation of translation gaps in 2021. 2. We will match service levels with the resources available to deliver them. 4.A. Conduct a citizen survey biennially in odd years to measure our performance and citizen preferences. 5.1. Evaluate the effectiveness of the central reception pilot program at Town Hall. 4.B. Evaluate inclusivity of Town community engagement processes. 6.A.1. Establish an initial set of Performance Measures for each department and develop centralized tool for tracking measures. 3. We will strive to ensure that the membership of our Boards and Commissions reflects the diversity of the community. 6.A. Implement a Town performance management system including appropriate measures. 6.B.1. Implement top priority process improvement tasks based on the recommendations of the internal task team. 6.B. Develop an organizational culture that encourages continuous process improvement. 6.C.1. Execute contract to scan and archive existing invoices. 4. We strive to gain meaningful input and participation from all community members. 6.C. Archive existing invoices in Laserfiche database. 8.A.1. Replace existing firewalls, conduct regular penetration tests, and enhance training and education for staff. 8.A. Minimize risk of becoming a victim of cybersecurity threats. 8.A.2. Evaluate ransomware risk and develop a mitigation plan. 5. We prioritize and support a culture of customer service throughout the organization. 9.A. We will continually evaluate the functionality of our website to ensure it serves the needs of our customers. 6. We support a culture of continuous improvement in our internal processes and service delivery. 7. We operate with transparency, maintaining open communication with all community members. 8. We will monitor for, and protect against, cybersecurity threats. 9. We will maintain a robust and transparent public-facing website. 1. We will ensure water service reliability and redundancy. 1.A. Secure a raw water supply from the Big Thompson River for the Glacier Creek Water Treatment Plant by 2026. 3.A.1. Consider implementing the recommendations of the Environmental Sustainability Task Force to support renewable energy and storage sources for use by the Town and by individual residents. 1.B. Replace the Glacier Creek Water Treatment Plant by 2026. 4.B.1. Develop and implement an annual budget contribution mechanism for facility expansion needs as identified in the Facilities Master Plan. Infrastructure - We have reliable, efficient, and up-to-date infrastructure serving our community and customers. 4057 2. We provide high quality, reliable, and sustainable electric service. 1.C. Develop a dedicated water distribution crew with the knowledge skills and ability for capital construction projects capable of replacing one (1) mile of pipe per year. 4.C.1. Install Phase 2 Town Hall Variable Refrigerant Flow cooling units. 2.A. Establish electric industry reliability metrics by 2022. 4.A.1. Develop, fund, and implement a stormwater drainage system maintenance program. 3. We will encourage and support renewable energy sources and storage. 3.A. Increase/enhance renewable energy sources and storage.5.B.1. Pursue grant funding for private and/or public flood mitigation projects. 4.A. Evaluate the service condition, safety, functionality, accessibility and land use restrictions of our 32 public buildings using a data-driven approach and document the outcomes in a Facilities Master Plan. 5.C.1. Develop a funding proposal to expand stormwater infrastructure and maintenance through a stormwater utility. 4. We will ensure that our facilities are well-maintained and meet the needs of Town Departments and the community. 4.B. Upgrade the quality, function and safety of the 5 busiest public facilities, to exceed the expectations of our guests by 2025. 5.D.1. Initiate discussions with the Colorado Water Conservation Board and FEMA regarding the process and costs of participating in the CRS program. 4.C. Pursue energy conservation projects that improve the efficiency of our buildings. 5. We will be proactive in our approach to mitigating flood risks including pursuing the implementation of the Stormwater Master Plan. 5.A. Upgrade and maintain our stormwater collection system to reduce the risk of flooding and damage to public and private property. 5.B. Pursue flood mitigation initiatives to reduce flood risk and increase public safety. 6. We will ensure access to high-speed, high-quality, reliable Trailblazer Broadband service. 5.C. Evaluate implementation options for a Stormwater Utility for the Estes Valley. 5.D. Explore the Community Rating System (CRS) program as a way to minimize flood insurance costs to the community. 6.A. We will complete construction of a broadband over fiber optic cable network for customers in the electric service area by 2024. Infrastructure.A. We will collaborate with community stakeholders to update our adopted transportation, drainage, and parking design standards and construction policies in the Development Code by 2025. 1. We will support a wide range of housing opportunities with a particular focus on workforce housing. 1.A. Allocate portion of excess revenue to workforce housing reserve fund. 1.A.1. Negotiate Development Agreement with AmericaWest for workforce housing on the Fish Hatchery site. 1.B. Prioritize Estes Park Development Code (EPDC) amendments on Community Development Master List that impact housing. 1.A.2. Evaluate additional funding streams for the workforce housing reserve fund. Outstanding Community Services - Estes Park is an exceptionally vibrant, diverse, inclusive, and active mountain community in which to live, work, and play, with housing available for all segments in our community. 4158 2. We will support the needs of our senior community.1.C. Incentivize Downtown Housing. 5.C.1. Team with community stakeholders to create and adopt a Management Plan for the Thumb Open Space. 3.A. Investigate the possibility of establishing one or more pocket parks in residential areas. 6.1. Complete new Comprehensive Plan in concert with Town and Larimer County stakeholders. 3. We support a family-friendly community and strive to be a family-friendly employer. 4.A. Participate in County Strategic Plan childcare capacity team.7.1. Complete the Americans with Disabilities Act Transition Plan. 4.B. Establish a reserve fund to fund investments in childcare. 8.A.1. Pursue "first right of refusal" purchase options on the top three opportunity sites identified in the Facilities Master Plan. 4. We will support a wide range of child care opportunities with a particular focus on infants and toddlers. 5.A. Develop a master plan for Town Parks and Open Space, in cooperation with the Recreation District and Estes Valley Land Trust. 5.B. In accordance with National Fire Protection Association Firewise USA criteria, overhaul outdated and aging landscaping in Children's Park, Riverwalk, Parking Structure picnic area, and Wiest Park by 2025. 5. We will expand and improve the durability, functionality, and efficiency of open space and public park infrastructure. 5.C. Improve the Thumb Open Space for public recreation as regulated by the Management Plan and Location and Extent review. 5.D. Specify the additional equipment, personnel and space needed to deliver and maintain high-quality landscaping in accordance with National Fire Protection Association Firewise USA criteria as required by new capital projects. 6. We will develop a new Comprehensive Plan and associated development code. 6.A. Complete a full rewrite of the Estes Park Development Code. 8.A. Develop a strategy and funding source for Town facility site acquisitions as identified in the Facilities Master Plan. 7. We are committed to improving community accessibility for residents and visitors with disabilities. 8. We will pursue land-banking opportunities as they align with the Strategic Plan. 1. We will promote policies that encourage environmental stewardship. 1.A. Modify codes and regulations to support alternative and distributed energy. 1.B.1. Create a fact sheet for residents and businesses that provides information and steps to follow for adding solar options to buildings. 1.B. Encourage solar energy options on new and established homes and businesses, including Town Buildings. 1.C.1. Develop and implement a plan to make the Rooftop Rodeo concessions and hospitality functions zero-waste. 2. We are committed to safeguarding the lives and property of the people we serve. 1.C. The Events and Visitor Services Department will reduce the environmental impacts of Town events. 2.1. Adopt the 2021 International Code Council Building Code updates, including the International Property Maintenance Code. 2.A. Evaluate and meet the sworn officer and dispatch staffing needs of the Police Department. 2.B.1. Implement Phase 3 of the Security Camera Project to address the needs of the Event Center and the associated parking area. Public Safety, Health, and Environment - Estes Park is a safe place to live, work, and visit within our extraordinary natural environment. 4259 3. We value the importance of maintaining a local emergency communication center to serve the residents and guests of the Estes Valley. 2.B. Integrate security camera systems in Town Hall, Visitor Center, Events Complex, and Museum. 9.1. Complete Community Planning Assistance for Wildfire (CPAW) process and begin implementation of recommendations. 2.C. Evaluate pandemic response plan. 4. We strive to enhance the safety of emergency responders in non-emergency and critical situations. 5. We support the County-wide Wasteshed Plan and will remain active partners with Larimer County in its implementation. 6. We believe in and support restorative practices as a way to build and repair relationships, as well as increase understanding about the impact of crime in the Estes Park Community. 7. We make data-driven decisions to improve and protect the quality of the environment in the Town. 8. We will train and prepare for responding to community emergencies. 9. We will be proactive in our approach to wildfire planning and mitigation in response to elevated fire risks in the Estes Valley and the surrounding area. 1. We will develop an inclusive, robust, and sustainable economy by making our economic development decisions based on a triple bottom line model, considering economic, social, and environmental impacts and benefits. 2.A. Evaluate and improve the Development Review process. 2.A.1. Work with the Estes Park Economic Development Corporation (EDC) to re- establish the EDC Code Committee. 4.A. Implement the Downtown Plan. 2. We will create and sustain a favorable business climate and we value building strong relationships with the business community. 5.A. In conjunction with the Comprehensive Plan process, identify and prioritize the Town's commercial corridors and prepare redevelopment plans and policies for them. 3. Our economy should be diverse, attracting and serving a broad range of current and potential stakeholders. 4. We recognize the importance of a vibrant, attractive, and economically-viable Downtown Core. 5. We support investment and revitalization in all of the Town's commercial corridors and centers. Robust Economy - We have a diverse, healthy year-round economy. 4360 6. The Town will support economic development efforts led by other organizations, including business attraction, retention, and expansion. 7. The Town will lead specific economic development efforts identified by the Town Board, such as the continued implementation of the Broadband Utility, and provision of electric and water services. 8. Town policies and actions will reflect a preference for local businesses. 9. The Town's policies should collectively support all demographic segments of the community, and strive to minimize barriers to a diverse, family-friendly community and robust workforce. 1. The Town will maintain up-to-date financial policies, tools, and controls that reflect the financial philosophy of the Board.1.A. Replace our enterprise financial system. 1.A.1. Develop a plan to replace the 1992 financial accounting system, including both financial and staffing considerations. 1.B. Develop general budget policies (i.e. reserves, one- time money for one-time exp, budget for full project up front, vacancies budgeted at 50% level, etc.).1.B.1. Review and propose updates to Planning Division fees. 2. Financial decisions for capital projects should be data-driven.1.C. Evaluate capital project ranking criteria. 1. We support having a sustainable, accessible, and efficient multimodal transportation network. 1.A. Street rehabilitation efforts will result in an average Pavement Condition Index of 73 or greater for the Town street network by 2024. 1.A.1. Complete the design and public outreach for the Cleave Street Improvement. Confirm community support and alignment with the updated Comprehensive plan prior to commencing construction. 1.B. Upgrade and maintain our public trail network to comply with adopted safety and disability standards. 1.B.1. Develop, fund, and implement a public trail maintenance program. 2. We will continue to reduce traffic congestion and improve traffic safety throughout the Town. 1.C. Study the possibility of adopting impact fees and fee-in- lieu mechanisms to assist in funding multi-modal transportation improvements. 2.A.1. Complete the design, bid package, and construction of the Fall River Trail segment funded by the MMOF and TAP grants. 2.A. Complete the Fall River Trail using available trails expansion funds, open space funds, and grant funding. 2.A.2. Pursue grant funding opportunities for construction of future segments of the Fall River Trail. Town Financial Health - We will maintain a strong and sustainable financial condition, balancing expenditures with available revenues, including adequate cash reserves for future needs and unanticipated emergencies. Transportation - We have safe, efficient, and well-maintained multi-modal transportation systems for pedestrians, cyclists, motorists, and transit riders. 4461 3. We will effectively communicate to residents and visitors the Town's parking and transportation options. 2.B. Develop funding options and strategies for street rehabilitation and trail expansion in advance of the 2024 expiration of 1A (including evaluation of renewing the 2014 1A sales tax initiative beyond 2024). 2.D.1. If funded, construct the Phase 1 roundabout improvements on US36 to accommodate safe access at Community Drive. 2.C. Develop funding strategies for the design, environmental clearance, and construction of the Moraine Avenue Multimodal Improvements. 2.E.1. Partner with CDOT to complete a corridor study for US 34 between Wonderview Avenue and Steamer Dr to include pedestrian, shuttle and general traffic accommodations, and options for direct access from US 34 to the parking structure. 4. We will make strategic, data-driven investments in technology that promotes the financial and environmental sustainability of the Town's parking and transportation assets. 2.D. Develop funding strategies and build the roundabout improvements at the intersection of US 36 and Community Drive. 2.F.1. Evaluate and refine the seasonal paid parking program (Phase 2 of the Downtown Parking Management Plan) implemented in 2021. 2.E. Develop funding and partnering strategies to commission a corridor study for US 34 between Wonderview Avenue and Steamer Drive to include pedestrian, shuttle and general traffic accommodations, and options for direct access from US 34 to the parking structure. 2.G.1. Partner with CDOT to explore expansion of Bustang to Estes service to include both the US 36 and US 34 corridors. 5. We will identify and leverage local, regional and national partnerships that strengthen and extend the Town's parking and transportation system.2.F. Implement the Downtown Parking Management Plan. 2.G.2. Create a new brand for Estes Transit and complementary strategic marketing plan to increase transit ridership. 2.G. Explore the potential for year-round local and regional transit service.2.H.1. Increase use of charging stations and electric vehicle tourism. 6. We will consider the potential impacts of technology changes, including electric and autonomous vehicles, in all transportation planning. 2.H. Implement the Electric Vehicle Infrastructure & Readiness Plan as grant funding opportunities coincide with Town needs.2H.2. Put the second electric trolley into service. 2.I. Develop a funding strategy to complete a Multimodal Transportation Master Plan within one year of completion of the Comprehensive Plan. 7.A.1. Apply for Safe Routes to Schools funding to implement sidewalk expansion on Graves Avenue and Community Drive to improve network connectivity with existing sidewalks on SH7, Community Drive, and Brodie Avenue. 7. We will continue to develop connectivity of trails in the Estes Valley in partnership with other entities, implementing the priorities in the Estes Valley Master Trails Plan. 7.A. Participate in the CDOT Safe Routes to Schools grant funding program to complete the bike and pedestrian network within one mile of Estes Park public schools. 4562