HomeMy WebLinkAboutMINUTES Transportation Advisory Board 04-17-19
Town of Estes Park, Larimer County, Colorado, April 17, 2019
Minutes of a regular meeting of the Transportation Advisory Board of the Town of Estes
Park, Larimer County, Colorado. Meeting held in the Room 202 of Town Hall on the 17th
day of April, 2019.
Present: Gordon Slack
Tom Street
Belle Morris
Stan Black
Ann Finley
Ron Wilcocks
Janice Crow
Also Present: Trustee Carlie Bangs, Town Board Liaison
Greg Muhonen, Public Works Director
Vanessa Solesbee, Parking & Transit Manager
Megan Van Hoozer, Public Works Administrative Assistant
David Hook, Engineering Manager
Absent: Linda Hanick
Chair Morris called the meeting to order at 12:03 p.m.
PUBLIC COMMENT:
No public comment.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES:
A motion was made and seconded (Slack/Wilcocks) to approve the March meeting
minutes with suggested edits and all were in favor.
COMPLETE STREETS RECOMMENDATION LETTER:
Chair Morris is still working through the creation of the letter. Morris will send to the TAB
once complete. TAB agreed that letter of support would be beneficial to the process.
Co-Chair Street asked if the creation of the Complete Streets document would require
an ordinance. Director Muhonen stated he’d gotten a question about why a resolution is
being done and it was requested this be reformatted to a policy rather than a resolution.
Per the TAB the main objective is that there be permanence to the process. A policy
would require Mayoral signature as opposed to a resolution which requires only a
Department Director’s signature. Muhonen stated that an ordinance becomes local law.
In order for private builders to be held to the same standard the Estes Valley
Development Code would need amended. Street asked if there if the policy can be
strictly enforced or if there is flexibility to ignore the policy. Muhonen stated there’d be
internal ramifications as a resolution. However, as a policy there’d be legal
ramifications.
Member Slack stated it would be beneficial to utilize work to occur on Fourth Street as
an example for the Town Board meeting to show the Trustees a situation in which this
processed has been applied.
Engineering Manager Hook drafted the Complete Streets document with updated
formatting. Hook will review and update the document annually. Hook reviewed the
revisions made with the TAB and provided copies along with the memo to the Town
Board (referencing attached policy). Any exceptions to the policy would require approval
by both the Public Works Director and the Town Administrator rather than the Board of
Adjustment as previously indicated. Muhonen offered to the TAB, an example of a
development review instance where the checklist could not be applied.
Transportation Advisory Board – April 17, 2019 – Page 2
A motion was made and seconded (Crow/Wilcocks) to send a letter of support
endorsing the Complete Streets policy and all were in favor.
CONCEPT OF CONGESTION PRICING:
Chair Morris introduced the concept of congestion pricing to the TAB. Morris Sent
supporting video/articles to the group last night to review for this discussion.
Congestion Pricing is a new tool in controlling traffic congestion and modifying driver
behavior. It encourages usage of public transportation thereby impacting traffic
congestion. Fees are collected via tolls, express lanes, and core charges. This method
is currently used in Stockholm, Sweden. Prior to implementing, there was only a 40%
approval of the concept but politicians instituted congestion pricing anyway. After six
months, the approval rating rose to 52%, then later to 70%. There are a variety of
industries using this method including airlines.
Congestion pricing uses collected funds for improving transit services as an alternative
transportation option. Morris suggested having a conversation with Rocky Mountain
National Park (RMNP) about the congestion pricing concept. If RMNP potentially
instituted an additional gate fee earmarked for gateway community’s transit, funding
could help with the Town’s shuttles. Morris stated that the traffic congestion and
pollution, due to visitors entering RMNP, is exacerbating the congestion issues in town.
Using transit, and the RMNP Hiker Shuttle, can reduce gasoline costs and improve
quality time for families. Currently, RMNP is considering working with the Town to have
digital messaging via the newly installed digital messaging via the newly installed digital
message signs. Public W orks will continue to work with the RMNP to discuss ideas.
Member Crow stated that a percentage of the RMNP entrance fee gate is earmarked for
RMNP’s transit operations only. Slack suggested having discussions with CDOT about
potential fees on state highways. Morris agreed stating that they’ve partnered in other
endeavors (FLAP, Loop). Director Muhonen stressed the importance of going through
the Town Board with these suggestions rather than going straight to CDOT.
Member Black stated paid parking is a form of congestion pricing and suggested the
TAB finish ironing out the implementation of paid parking before taking on another
initiative. Black does not support recommending RMNP raise their entrance fees for this
endeavor since it is public land.
Trustee Liaison Bangs thanked Morris for bringing this concept to the table. Bangs
stated that she appreciates the tool being offered and discussed with the TAB but this
may need to wait for other things to finish being worked through. She said there may be
a future for this to be implemented in the downtown corridor. It will have to be discussed
in the future.
Wilcocks expressed concern about comingling Town needs and RMNP needs. There
would then be a lack of specific information about the Town. Additionally, a goal
creating an empty lane due should not be considered due to the high expense of use.
Co-Chair Street stated Kyle Patterson’s press release showed different concepts which
will be shared with the public in a couple months. The question is whether or not funding
will be made available to initiate changes.
TAB MEMBER SELECTION STATUS:
Trustee Liaison Bangs stated that an interview committee has been selected. Morris
asked about potential applicant conflicts of interest like representatives of employing
agencies. There are no existing concerns about the interviewees and trusts that a
member would recuse themselves if necessary. The expectation would be that whomever
is selected, regardless of outside influences, they would p articipate as a citizen. If
someone is representing an agency, they’re welcome to attend all meetings and offer
updates as John Hannon of RMNP has done.
Transportation Advisory Board – April 17, 2019 – Page 3
PROJECT UPDATES (G. Muhonen – Public Works Administration)
Director Muhonen reported on the Community Drive / US 36 roundabout funding
difficulties. The Town Board signed off in support of the change order and the design
teams have also executed the change order. Progress is being made. Once the new
designs are complete Muhonen will bring back to the TAB for review.
PROJECT UPDATES (D. Hook – Engineering Manager)
US 34 & MacGregor Avenue Roundabout: Director Muhonen and Supervisor Berg will be
meeting with CDOT regarding appropriate roundabout landscaping,
4th Street / Elkhorn / Town-wide.
Today was the bid opening for the combined overlay project. Coulson Excavating was the
low bidder with numbers coming in under the engineer’s budget. The Engineering Division
is working to prepare the Town Board memo for next week’s meeting. Contract execution
and project start date will be coming soon and all are hoping for the Preconstruction
Meeting to occur in early May.
Muhonen stated there is a potential margin for contingency. Muhonen will send an email
to CDOT to confirm their preference on where to spend the remaining dollars. Muhonen
is hoping for the dollars to go toward the US 36/US 34 intersection.
Brodie Avenue Improvements: The final design plans for Brodie Avenue were received
earlier this week. The Engineering Division is working through final clearances and CDOT
approval per the grant funding requirements. Hook is hoping to publish requests for bids
next week with short window. Construction is anticipated to begin after Memorial Day.
PROJECT UPDATES (V. Solesbee – Parking & Transit Manager)
Parking Warrant: Solesbee thanked the TAB members for their attendance at the special meeting
scheduled yesterday. The information is being combined and incorporated for next week’s Town
Board Study Session. Solesbee will provide the Trustees all the content of warrant but will be sure
to include suggestions received in yesterday’s meeting. Real time parking availability is also being
presented at next week’s meeting.
Estes Transit: Shuttle season begins June 22. The Town received significant sponsorship of
shuttles this year. Solesbee is finalizing shuttle stop signage and plans for shuttle maps to be
completed tonight and reflected on the website by the end of the week.
DMS: Currently working on international symbology for added sign usage.
CDOT Agreement for 2nd Electronic Bus / Charging Station: Once this agreement has been
approved, the Town will immediately order the charging station but will hold off on ordering the
next bus.
CDOT Audit: The audit will occur in June and will be focused on operations and recordkeeping.
The Parking & Transit division is now looking for volunteers to assist visitors with getting on and
off the shuttles/buses. Manager Solesbee needs to confirm ability, but would potentially like to
recruit a volunteer license plate recognition (LPR) driver. Electronic vehicles will not work out for
this initiative due both the driving and the technology sucking up the vehicle’s electricity. Muhonen
stated that the seasonal staff will be leaving end of August, therefore he asked TAB members to
volunteer in September and October to complete collection of data.
P&T Strategic Plan Goals: Transit goals are due April 25. Solesbee requested input from TAB
members. Solesbee prefers that an equal number of goals be submitted for both parking and
transit and walked through the focus areas for this initiative.
One goal mentioned was to redirect the RMNP Hiker Shuttle from the Visitor Cener to the Events
Complex. Member Slack stated that one downside to this is that there are no restrooms at that
stop. Member Crow stated that for shuttles/buses it would be a 40-minute turn. The TAB
discussed different route options. All are hoping for the Green Route to be reimplemented.
Member Wilcocks stated he’s glad to see that Cleave Street is on the list of 1-year goals. Muhonen
stated that Public Works will definitely bring that design back to the TAB as well as have
community meetings.
Transportation Advisory Board – April 17, 2019 – Page 4
Member Finley asked about the possibility of transit up and down the valley. Solesbee stated her
strong desire to add RTA to the document if TAB is supportive.
Chair Morris inquired about a roundabout at Steamer Drive and US 34, and any pedestrian
components to access the opposite side of US 34. Muhonen stated there will be a corridor
assessment from Summit to US 36. The consultant will look at Complete Streets solutions to
devise a plan. Solesbee met with the Police Department (PD) on these safety concerns and is
hoping to do something different this year.
Member Black stated the importance of addressing the influx of tour buses and larger RVs. Both
cause significant congestion and contribute to safety concerns. Muhonen stated this is an ongoing
conversation with PD and a lounge is being added at the Visitor Center for tour bus drivers. This
needs communicated to the tour bus drivers. Solesbee would like added to website.
Member Wilcocks suggested that all TAB members have a printed copy of the Downtown Plan.
Trustee Liaison Bangs suggested that the TAB Chair have a copy at a minimum.
OTHER BUSINESS
Chair Morris reviewed the suggested Meeting Code of Conduct with the TAB, and
discussed a couple examples of areas needing improvement. Morris stated that the goal
is to offer all perspectives while leaving time for all to speak.
Solesbee stated that it’s important, from the Public W orks angle, to be able to capture all
concerns and ideas being shared. This is difficult when there are multiple discussions. All
were in favor of the guidelines set forth.
With no other business to discuss, Chair Morris adjourned the meeting at 2:00 p.m.
Recording Secretary
Megan Van Hoozer, Public Works Department