HomeMy WebLinkAboutMINUTES Transportation Advisory Board 02-21-18
Town of Estes Park, Larimer County, Colorado, February 21, 2018
Minutes of a regular meeting of the Transportation Advisory Board of the Town of Estes
Park, Larimer County, Colorado. Meeting held in the Room 203 of Town Hall on the 21st
day of February, 2018.
Present: Kimberly Campbell
Gordon Slack
Ann Finley
Tom Street
Belle Morris
Stan Black
Amy Hamrick
Ken Zornes
Also Present: Bob Holcomb, Town Board Liaison
Greg Muhonen, Public Works Director
David Hook, Engineering Manager
Megan Van Hoozer, Public Works Administrative Assistant
Absent: Lochen Wood, RMNP
Claudine Perrault
Chair Morris called the meeting to order at 12:00 p.m.
PUBLIC COMMENT:
No public comment.
A motion was made and seconded (Slack/Finley) to approve the January minutes and
all were in favor.
TAB BY-LAW MODIFICATION
The TAB reviewed the suggested by-law modifications. A motion was made and
seconded (Slack/Hamrick) to accept the suggested modifications and all were in favor.
Assistant Town Administrator Machalek will present the modified by-laws to the Town
Board for adoption.
A discussion was then held regarding email votes that are primarily for document
approval in preparation of submission to the Town Board. Clarification is needed on
what business can be discussed/held via email.
Director Muhonen referenced other advisory board operations and a recent comment by
a Town Board Trustee asking members to maintain awareness of the Sunshine Law to
ensure violations don’t occur. Email communications with all members is considered a
meeting and cannot occur. The suggestion was made to have all discussions in a
regular meeting.
Muhonen then suggested that when new members are brought on board, there should
be a common practice to review with the Chairperson, the
roles/responsibilities/boundaries, etc. of the advisory board.
SHUTTLE UPDATE
Transit Program Manager, Brian Wells, presented this month’s Shuttle Committee
update. Sandy Osterman has asked to step down as the Shuttle Committee
Transportation Advisory Board – February 21, 2017 – Page 2
representative. The Shuttle Committee is working on appointing a replacement. Wells is
the intermediate representative.
Wells summarized 2017 shuttle statistics related to routes and timing. Suggestions have
been received to move the hiker shuttle stop to the east side of the Visitor Center and
leave the Town shuttle stop on the south side. This is being discussed and all affects
considered.
McDonald Transit, the contracting service provider for the Town shuttles, has raised the
renewal for 2018 from $56.48/hr. to $63/hr. As a result, the Green Route will have to be
removed from the system. It would cost over $40K to reinstate this route.
Sponsorship for the shuttles is in full force and sponsors c an only be acquired until
March 31, 2018. The current sponsor goal is $13K.
Member Slack questioned the ridership numbers for 2017 being lower than 2016. Wells
stated that the shuttles ended an hour earlier in 2017 and did not provide spring service.
He also reported that the J-1 students more frequently used bicycles in 2017 and that
the RMNP hiker shuttle had more day trippers.
Member Hamrick asked if there has been any progress on getting shuttles to run
through the parking structure. Director Muhonen stated that the Mayor called a meeting
with the US Bureau of Reclamation (BOR) leadership and legislative representatives to
discuss the matter. Terry Stroh, the author of the existing Special Use Permit (SUP)
was receptive to the proposal, but only with an addition of electronic gates acting as a
service gate and a gate for the shuttles. Muhonen was excited to hear this possibility.
Public W orks is currently reviewing, however the need remains for a determination on
reinstating the Green Route prior to doing going through this effort.
PROJECT UPDATES, Greg Muhonen, Public Works Director
Downtown Estes Loop:
The TAC committee met last week. CDOT is currently getting appraisals and providing
offers to seven key property owners for the Right of Way acquisitions required.
The consultant, AECOM reached 70% design completion and will be attending the
March TAB meeting to provide updates. CDOT approved diagonal parking on Moraine
Ave. and is providing for a bike lane.
Downtown Parking Management Plan (DPMP):
Director Muhonen requested feedback regarding the potential request that the savings
from the parking garage be used to reinstate the shuttle’s Green Route at a cost of
approximately $41K. This request would be part of the March 27 Town Board Meeting
as a supplemental budget request. Muhonen plans to present other ideas for potential
expenditures against these savings including approximately $40K for counters at the
parking structure to properly track and monitor structure usage .
Member Campbell stated that, until there is better utilization of the parking structure, it
doesn’t seem appropriate to utilize funds on the Green Route, but that the funds should
be used to provide better service for special events. Since the goal is to get
visitors/residents to walk more, why provide shuttle service at the parking garage rather
than require they cross the bridge to the Visitor Center for the shuttle stop? Muhonen
Transportation Advisory Board – February 21, 2017 – Page 3
indicated the reason is less about ease for the residents/visitors and more to do with
maintaining reliable headway. Left turns onto US 34 from the Visitor Center is incredibly
difficult in peak season and creates shuttle delays.
It was further discussed that with the funds being available now, and the BOR be ing
willing to work with the Town on the SUP now, this seems the most appropriate time to
make these requests. The need will arise and the situation may be different.
Member Hamrick inquired about the future potential for an employee shuttle. Per Wells,
the 2016 4-week test route for employees parking at the Events Complex was a big flop.
Member Campbell clarified that the test route took place in the morning but the real
need is for those with an afternoon shift.
After more in-depth discussions related to existing shuttle routes, ridership and potential
new routes, the TAB expressed full support of Director Muhonen’s suggestion related to
expenditures against parking structure savings.
Director Muhonen discussed the plan for rolling out the DPMP (i.e. logistics,
administrative details, etc.). He stated there is potential for reorganization involving
moving transit operations from the Community Services Department and moving it into
Public Works stating it makes sense to combine transit and parking management in the
early years. This would also create a need for the Shuttle Committee to potentially
combine with the Transportation Advisory Board. The Shuttle Committee would need an
opportunity to review and assess this transition.
Muhonen requested the TAB provide guidance on this topic asking if the members
believe a Shuttle Committee member should fully join the TAB. Manager Wells
described the current Shuttle Committee functions stating they only meet three to five
times each year. Wells will confirm, with the Shuttle Committee, their thoughts on the
matter and will report at the regular March TAB meeting the reactions or ideas
expressed.
Stormwater Master Plan:
This process is moving along. There was recently a presentation at a Town Board Study
Session wherein the Trustees requested public outreach occur and that Public Works
return with the feedback received.
PROJECT UPDATES, David Hook, Engineering Manager
2018 Street Improvement Program (STIP):
This year’s street improvement program will include chipseal, crack seal, and mill &
overlays on several identified streets throughout Estes Park. This presentation will be
given at the Town Board Study Session next week.
Fall River Trail Extension:
The recent application for grant funding from the Land Conversation and Water Fund in
the amount of $400,000 was approved and the funding has been granted. The
construction is still anticipated to take place in 2019 on Phase 3 of this project mean ing
a trail will be constructed beginning at David Drive and extend to the Rocky Mountain
National Park’s Fall River Entrance.
Brodie Avenue Improvements:
Transportation Advisory Board – February 21, 2017 – Page 4
The design of the Brodie Avenue improvements is progressing well. The public meeting
held in January at the school had a very low turnout.
Next week, the design consultant should have 90% drawings. The plan is to perform
construction while school is not in session. The Town is hoping to have a decision on
the Safe Routes to School (“SRTS”) grant soon.
The TAB requested the Brodie drawings be provided for review by the entire group .
Manager Hook extended his apology for not realizing the practice of bringing drawings
related to trails for feedback from the TAB. During the meeting, the 30% drawings were
delivered for review by the members. Director Muhonen and Manager Hook explained
the trail portions of the drawings and comments were collected.
Moraine Avenue Improvements:
The Moraine Avenue Bridge project is moving along. The project is currently at a point
where the contractor is constructing rather than destructing. They’re pouring the bottom
slab of the box culvert this week. The rebar and walls have been installed/erected.
Discussions continue regarding construction acceleration to recoup time lost. Schedules
continue to be subject to weather. If there is no acceleration, completion cannot take
place until the end of June. Ideally, with an accelerated date, completion would be by
the end of May. There is a plan that is coming together but there is never a guarantee.
There was a public meeting with downtown business owners today and attendance was
very good. The biggest complaint was about a decline in business due to the Moraine
closure and business owners are distressed about the April closure of Elkhorn Ave.
US36 / Community Drive Turn Lane:
Public Works will be taking a design contract to the Town Board meeting next week for
approval. There is an existing plan to install both a left-turn and right-turn lane based on
a recent traffic study from the Community Center project. There is a scenario where
construction could occur this fall. Funding may be an issue and would delay
construction on this project until 2019.
DMS – Dynamic Message Sign Installation
Manager Hook is currently working with the low bidder to reach an agreement for a
reduction of the bid amount to fit the Town’s budget threshold. The Town of Estes
Park’s Streets and Parks Divisions would take on some of the identified work to allow
removal from the contract scope. These negotiations would equate to a reduction of
approximately $95K from the original bid of $219K. The Town would require a
construction contract of approximately $125K in order to move forward. Out of pocket
costs will take place for materials needed and this has been budgeted. It is critical to get
a contract in place due to the potential of long lead times on needed items.
OTHER BUSINESS
No other business identified.
With no other business to discuss, Chair Morris adjourned the meeting at 1:59 p.m.